|   Table
              of Contents Study
            Areas: Slavery Anti-Slavery Free
            Persons of Color Underground
            Railroad The
            Violent Decade  US
            Colored Troops Civil
            War  
     |   Chapter
            Eight Backlash, Violence and Fear:
 The Violent Decade (continued)
  Exciting
            TimesEven
              as Joseph Bustill was stepping onto the railroad
              station platform in January 1856 and looking around at his new
              home, three brothers in Clear Springs, Maryland were planning a
              daring escape that would land them and their families in his hands.
              Not that these men knew anything about Joseph Bustill, or about
              Harrisburg, or about the new methods or escape routes that were
              being put in place. They only knew that they had to escape the
              severe poverty in which their owners kept them, their wives and
              children.  The
          oldest brother, Owen Taylor, seems to have been the leader and the
          one who planned the escape, initially set for New Years Day. Circumstances,
          perhaps severe weather, caused the Taylor brothers to postpone the
          escape until later, and they finally settled on Easter Sunday for their
          attempt, which in 1856 fell unusually early, on 23 March. Taking advantage
          of the holiday from work, Owen Taylor and his wife Mary Ann quietly
          led their child Edward to the livery stable on the estate, where they
          hitched two horses to his master’s carriage in preparation for
          a dash north into Pennsylvania.  Rendezvousing
          with Owen in the stable that evening was his brother Otho and his wife
          and the couple’s two small children, and another brother, Benjamin,
          who was unmarried. Once everyone was situated, this large group of
          five adults and three children nonchalantly drove the carriage down
          the farm lane onto the open road and headed straight to Hagerstown,
          about eight miles to the east, keeping a brisk but not overly rapid
          pace. They intended to present the appearance of a large family in
          a fine carriage being driven by a servant to their evening destination
          on Easter night. The urge to light out at top speed must have been
          strong, but they knew enough to trust in the anonymity of being just
          one more carriage on the busy road to Hagerstown.  Once
          through that town they turned north and drove their carriage at top
          speed across the Mason-Dixon Line the entire twenty-four miles to Chambersburg,
          the first place they dared to stop and rest. They drove steadily through
          the darkness, arriving in Chambersburg in the early morning hours.
          Their mode of travel then changed, and whether this was an improvisation,
          or part of a larger plan, may never be known.  Chambersburg
          was a valuable station on the Underground Railroad, receiving large
          numbers of freedom seekers who crossed from Maryland into Franklin
          County and then found their way into the well-established African American
          communities in Greencastle or Mercersburg. But the surrounding countryside
          was also friendly ground for slave catchers, who patrolled its ridges
          and valleys, always on watch for weary fugitives. Those who made it
          through the open country safely to Chambersburg were cared for by local
          African American activists, many of whom lived in the town’s
          South Ward.  From
          here, fugitive slaves were taken, usually by foot, to Shippensburg
          and then on to Harrisburg, by way of Carlisle. This was the route that
          George Cole, a free African American resident of Chambersburg, was
          following in 1847 as he guided thirteen freedom seekers along the iron
          forge trail, eventually ending up at Daniel Kauffman’s barn near
          Boiling Springs. On this Easter night, 1856, though, the Taylor party
          took a more direct and expeditious route to Harrisburg. Leaving the
          carriage and horses at a local tavern, the Taylors boarded railroad
          cars, and in a few hours rode directly into the heart of Harrisburg
          on the Cumberland Valley Railroad.113  Certainly,
          there was good reason for them to depart Chambersburg in haste. The
          owner of Owen Taylor’s wife and children, John S. Fiery, was
          rapidly on their trail, tracking them to Chambersburg within hours
          of their escape. There he recovered the horses and carriage, and upon
          making inquiries, also discovered that the Taylors had then gone to
          Harrisburg. John Fiery and his slave catching helpers immediately set
          out for Harrisburg, hoping to catch the large group resting, but again
          he and his party arrived too late. All he found was a less-than-helpful
          Joseph Bustill.  If
          the Harrisburg activists had used the traditional routes and methods—guiding
          the families by foot along the turnpike road to the Rutherford farms
          in Swatara Township—John Fiery and his men would have easily
          caught up with them. Considering that his party arrived in Harrisburg
          less than twelve hours behind the fugitives, it is likely that he would
          have run them down on the turnpike before they even reached the first
          Rutherford farm.  That,
          perhaps, was what Fiery intended. The Rutherford farms were, by this
          time, known harbors for wayward slaves, and the turnpike road was sometimes
          watched by those sympathetic to slave holders. Most of Harrisburg’s
          white residents were not sympathetic toward abolitionists and Underground
          Railroad activities, and even through the end of the Civil War never
          would be. The popular ouster of Richard McAllister three years earlier,
          it should be remembered, was not so much an anti-slavery statement
          as it was a backlash against mercenary slave hunting and corruption.
          Slave owners, backed by the Fugitive Slave Law, still had the expectation
          of success in Harrisburg, but that was about to change.  John
          S. Fiery presented Bustill’s reformed Harrisburg operation with
          its first test, and it passed. The Washington County, Maryland slaveholder
          was foiled in his attempts to capture his three slaves and the slaves
          of his father, Henry Fiery, by the bold and inventive tactics of the
          newly formed Harrisburg Fugitive Slave Society.  The
          difference was the rapid response of Harrisburg’s activists.
          The Taylor fugitives arrived at the Cumberland Valley Railroad Station
          on Chestnut Street at 8:30 a.m. It is possible that Joseph Bustill
          and his Harrisburg team were expecting the fugitives, particularly
          if the activists in Chambersburg were the ones responsible for putting
          the family on board the night train. If so, advance notice in the form
          of a telegraph might have been sent. Regardless of whether the Harrisburg
          team received notice, the families were processed quickly; they were
          fed, cared for, and briefed on the next part of their journey, all
          within the space of a few hours. By three o’clock that afternoon,
          Bustill’s workers had placed all the fugitives on the cars of
          the Philadelphia and Reading Railroad, and by twenty minutes past three,
          the train left Harrisburg for Reading. The haste was necessitated by
          the belief, possibly communicated to Bustill by Chambersburg activists,
          that the Fiery’s were on their way.  Inspired
          by their use of a night train to reach Harrisburg, Bustill quickly
          devised a scheme to continue using this mode of transportation, and
          he either contacted his associate in Reading, an African American barber
          and fellow agent named Grayson Snowdon Nelson, to make arrangements
          for their safe arrival and immediate forwarding to Philadelphia, or
          he provided the Taylors with information to locate Nelson. The plan
          worked beautifully, and the freedom seekers arrived safely in Philadelphia
          just as the Fierys reached Harrisburg.114   
 After
              the departure of the Taylors, but before the arrival
              of their Southern owners, Joseph Bustill sat down to compose a
              letter to William Still, in Philadelphia, explaining the circumstances
              and his reasons for using the train, which was a daring and risky
              venture. The letter itself may have been risky, as Bustill, a novice
              stationmaster, revealed his inexperience in the lack of code words
              to disguise the operation: 
        Friend Still: I suppose
              you have seen those five large and three small packages I sent
              by way of Reading, consisting of three men and women and children.
              They arrived here this morning at 8:30 o'clock and left twenty
              minutes past three. You will please send me any information likely
              to prove interesting in relation to them. Lately we have formed
              a society here called the Fugitive Slave Society. This is our first
              case, and I hope it will prove entirely successful. When you write,
              please inform me what signs or symbol you make use of in your dispatches,
              and any other information in relation to operations of the UR.
              Our reason for sending by the Reading Road, was to gain time; it
              is expected the owners will be in town this afternoon and by this
              Road we gained five hours' time, which is a matter of much importance,
              and we may have occasion to use it sometime in future. In great
              haste. Yours with great respect, Joseph C. Bustill.115 “This
          is our first case, and I hope it will prove entirely successful.” Joseph
          Bustill’s optimistic line indicates that the break with the old
          methods was complete. The new Harrisburg Fugitive Slave Society was
          now running the local Underground Railroad operation. Its success in
          this first endeavor, which had apparently caught it off guard—Bustill’s
          request to be informed of the standard signs and symbols shows he had
          not yet worked out all the details—stoked the confidence of its
          agents. They had the backing of a well-organized network that stretched
          from Pittsburgh to Philadelphia, and able captains at the helm in Martin
          R. Delany in the west and William Still in the east.  Bustill even
          became brazen enough, after receiving notice that the Taylors were
          safe, to taunt the owners when they arrived in Harrisburg, stringing
          them along with promises that a deal might be worked out whereby they
          could still recover their slaves. John Fiery remained in contact with
          Bustill, and at his suggestion sent a power of attorney letter to the
          Harrisburg abolitionist offering “to liberate the oldest [Taylor
          brother] in a year, and the remainder in proportional time, if they
          will come back; or to sell them their time for $1300.”  Bustill continued
          to encourage the Maryland slaveholder through May of that year, even
          though he had no intention of ever arranging for the return of the
          Taylor families, who by then were safely settled in St. Catharines
          in Canada West, well beyond the reach of the Fugitive Slave Law. He
          forwarded letters from John Fiery to the former slaves, and from the
          Taylors to their former master, who doggedly bore a steady stream of
          costs and fees as Bustill gave him just enough information to remain
          hopeful that he would eventually recover his slaves. In a 28 April
          1856 letter to Still, Bustill asked, “Or if you can send me word
          where they are, I will endeavor to write to them for his special satisfaction;
          or if you cannot do either, send me your latest information, for I
          intend to make him spend a few more dollars, and if possible get a
          little sicker of this bad job. Do try and send him a few bitter pills
          for his weak nerves and disturbed mind.”  Finally,
          in late May, Bustill tired of the game and broke the news to John Fiery,
          who had again come to Harrisburg to press his case. Writing to Still
          in a letter dated 26 May 1856, Bustill wrote of recent operations,
          then added at the end, “I have nothing more to send you, except
          that John Fiery has visited us again and much to his chagrin received
          the information of their being in Canada.”116  Joseph Bustill
          worked on perfecting his Harrisburg operation through the late spring,
          having plenty of opportunities to fine-tune his tactics. Late May and
          early June proved to be a very busy period, not only for Bustill in
          Harrisburg, but for William Still in Philadelphia as well, as the incoming
          fugitive slaves funneled through the network increased in numbers,
          until the system reached an “anxious state” on the last
          day of the month as Still strained to find resources for four separate
          parties that arrived at his doorstep within the space of a few days.  One that
          passed through Harrisburg consisted of a white lady named Emily Ann
          Mahoney and her ten-year-old daughter, accompanied by an African American
          man named David Lewis, the slave of Joshua Pusey of Leesburg, Virginia.
          Their story mimicked that of the Taylor family in several respects:
          the couple commandeered Pusey’s horse to pull a rented carriage,
          and the slave posed as the coachman for the lady and her daughter as
          they drove from Leesburg, Virginia, straight to Chambersburg, where
          they stopped at a hotel.  In this case,
          they stayed the night in the hotel, but upon checking out the next
          morning, the hotel keeper, having become suspicious, stated to the
          woman “that he ‘believed that it was an Underground Rail
          Road movement;’ but being an obliging hotel-keeper, he assured
          her at the same time, that he ‘would not betray them.’” He
          then added that they would find friends and aid in Harrisburg.  The family,
          knowing that they were still far removed from a safe haven, chose not
          to trust the hotelkeeper, and decided to switch their mode of transportation.
          Again, the Cumberland Valley Railroad became the chosen method of getting
          rapidly out of a dangerous situation, so they left Pusey’s horse
          and the rented carriage at the inn and boarded the next passenger train
          to Harrisburg, where they sought out members of the local Fugitive
          Slave Society. Within hours of their arrival in Harrisburg, Bustill
          or one of his workers had given them instructions for locating the
          office of the Vigilance Committee in Philadelphia, and put them on
          the next passenger train to Philadelphia, where they arrived safely
          on 31 May.117  Although
          the arrival of this family in Harrisburg presented an urgent situation
          to the members of the Fugitive Slave Society, it did not severely tax
          their resources, as the family had rested the previous evening and
          were prepared to pay for their own train tickets. This was probably
          just as well, as Bustill and his workers suddenly found themselves
          scrambling to find aid for six persons who arrived in Harrisburg greatly
          in need of help. They straggled into town at the end of May after spending
          a week on the road, hiding from potential captors, faring “as
          they could, out in the woods, over the mountains,” until they
          eventually found their way across the Susquehanna River to friends.  The group
          consisted of two men, two women and two children, all working together
          to get away from two separate masters in the Hagerstown area. They
          had initially escaped at night in a wagon drawn by two horses, but
          began experiencing setbacks almost immediately. They had only gone
          about nine miles when their wagon broke down. As they were gathered
          around, trying to decide what to do, a pair of white men descended
          on them out of the darkness and tried to seize their horses. The two
          men in the group fought desperately with the whites, fiercely refusing
          to allow their plans for freedom to be stolen away from them. The fight
          was violent and quick, and when it was over the two white men lay unconscious
          in the road.  Although
          their attackers were down, the situation for the freedom seekers had
          gone from serious to critical. Not only were they broken down on a
          dangerous stretch of road, but they now also had two severely beaten
          white men at their feet. The only solution was to unhitch both horses
          from the wagon and saddle them, distributing three persons on each
          horse. In this manner, they made a desperate dash for the Pennsylvania
          border, which they knew was not far away.  They rode
          through the night, riding deep into Pennsylvania some thirty or forty
          miles, not stopping until the exhaustion of their mounts forced a halt.
          With single-minded purpose, they abandoned the horses and walked, only
          stopping when daylight forced them into hiding. They walked by night
          and hid by day for a week, not finding any aid to speak of until they
          reached Harrisburg on the last or next to last day of May.118  When the
          group reached Harrisburg and the attention of Joseph Bustill, the resistance
          leader knew that they had to work fast if they were going to save these
          hardy souls from recapture. All six were in desperate need of care,
          having survived for a week in open country. They needed food, medical
          attention, new clothing, and if possible, some rest. He made arrangements
          to fulfill their needs, while at the same time planning on how to get
          them quickly to a safer place.  They had
          not made contact with Underground Railroad agents prior to their arrival
          in Harrisburg, and therefore had not been smuggled in. Unfriendly as
          well as friendly eyes had observed their arrival, and Bustill knew
          that the telegraph wires were probably already conveying a description
          of this ragged bunch to interested sources below the Mason-Dixon Line.
          He was correct.  Within hours,
          the Washington County owners, George Schaeffer, a miller, and David
          Claggett, a farmer, were making their own arrangements to reclaim their
          wayward property, now that they finally knew their location. On 31
          May, Schaeffer telegraphed an alert to the Philadelphia police informing
          them that his runaway slaves were believed to be on the direct train
          from Harrisburg to Philadelphia. His telegram offered a $1300 reward
          for their capture, and he requested that a police officer be posted
          at the Pennsylvania Railroad depot to intercept them before they made
          contact with the local Vigilance Committee.119  Although
          Joseph Bustill was not aware of this telegram, William Still was. In
          the early evening of 31 May, Still returned to the office of the Vigilance
          Committee after dinner to find an unexpected guest, a highly agitated
          Philadelphia police officer, waiting there for him. The appearance
          of this officer of the law must have caused him considerable concern,
          particularly as he was highly aware of the illegality of the Vigilance
          Committee’s actions.  The policeman,
          who was also aware of the Vigilance Committee’s activities, was
          not there to arrest anyone, though. He told Still about the telegram
          from Schaeffer, and explained that he had been assigned to arrest the
          fugitives when they arrived at the railroad depot, but he was morally
          burdened by his assignment, explaining, “I am not the man for
          this business.” He warned Still that the information he was sharing
          was confidential, and that he had only come to him as a courtesy, “so
          that [the Vigilance Committee] may be on the look-out” for the
          fugitives from Harrisburg.  Still was
          impressed by the seeming sincerity of his visitor, but did not entirely
          trust him. All throughout the policeman’s story Still was nervously
          eyeing an unopened telegram that had been laid on his desk while he
          had been away for dinner. He suspected that it had come from Joseph
          Bustill and that it concerned the fugitives in question. He gestured
          to the telegram and told the policeman that it might confirm the story.
          Still opened and read the telegram silently, then folded it and told
          the officer that it was indeed about the same party, and “that
          they would be duly looked after.” Satisfied that he had accomplished
          his goal, and perhaps now somewhat unburdened, the policeman then left
          the office to send a return telegram to the Maryland slave holder that
          he would be posted at the station that night. The telegram that Still
          received read: 
        HARRISBURG, May 31st,
              1856.WM. STILL, N. 5th St.:--I have sent via at two o'clock four large and
          two small hams.
 JOS. C. BUSTILL.120
  The six “hams” arrived
          later that evening, but not at the Pennsylvania Railroad depot, where
          the policeman waited. They arrived about ten blocks away at the Reading
          and Philadelphia depot, as indicated in the dispatch from Bustill.
          The freedom seekers who had boarded the train in Harrisburg at two
          p.m. earlier that day were Charles Bird, George Dorsey, Dorsey’s
          sister Angeline Brown and her two children Albert and Charles, and
          Jane Scott.  All but Bird
          were the slaves of George Schaeffer, who had a mill on the Antietam
          Creek, and who regularly terrorized his slaves with threats to sell
          them off. Most of George and Angeline’s family, their mother
          and ten more brothers and sisters, were still enslaved on the Schaeffer
          estate. They, along with Angeline’s two young sons, were the
          only ones able to get away.  Because of
          the suspicious circumstances surrounding this party, William Still
          had considerable difficulty in finding shelter for them. Many of his
          usual hosts refused to take these freedom seekers in, after hearing
          that the police had been assigned to watch for them. Finally, he found
          a safe spot, placing all six with a widow named Ann Laws, who agreed
          to keep them as long as necessary.121   Bustill Reorganizes
          The Harrisburg NetworkBy late May,
          it appears that Joseph Bustill had developed an operating plan for
          his station in Harrisburg, and it was a true reorganization. He needed
          to inform William Still of his plan and methods, and he needed to do
          so in plain language, to avoid the possible misinterpretation inherent
          in the use of code words. But he did not want to risk trusting a message
          of that importance to the mails, and certainly not to the telegraph.  An opportunity
          presented itself in the person of Harrisburg activist John F. Williams,
          a mutual friend of both Bustill and Still. When he learned that Williams
          was making a trip to Philadelphia, Bustill asked his friend to hand
          deliver a letter to William Still at the Vigilance Committee office,
          detailing his plans for future operations. In the letter, Bustill revealed
          that the Harrisburg station would continue to send fugitive slaves
          directly to Philadelphia by way of Reading, with the understanding
          that William Still would then forward the fugitives to stations on
          the New York-Canada border by train.  Bustill preferred
          to use the Philadelphia and Reading line, and specifically a route
          that left Harrisburg at 1:30 a.m. and arrived at Philadelphia’s
          Broad and Callowhill Streets depot at 5:00 a.m. Referring to this late
          night run as the “Lightning Train,” Bustill, noted that
          he would send a telegram to Still’s office before the closing
          hour on any day that he intended to send fugitives by this route.  Prior to
          this, there are indications that Bustill had sent, or had planned to
          send, fugitives by train to an Underground Railroad operator in Auburn,
          New York, but as he noted in his letter, “as the traveling season
          has commenced and this is the southern route for Niagara Falls,” that
          option was too public for his tastes, “except in cases of great
          danger.”122  Notably,
          Bustill’s plan did not make use of the overland route depended
          upon by previous activists. No longer would arriving fugitives be guided
          by foot or taken by wagon to Swatara Township, then to Linglestown
          and points further north. This plan did two important things: It acknowledged
          the graying of the old guard, men such as Frederick Kelker, William
          Rutherford, Edward Bennett, and William Jones, and it recognized the
          speed with which Southern slaveholders were reacting to the escape
          of slaves.  During the
          time that William McAllister held the office of Slave Commissioner,
          he had, even if improperly, developed a network of informants to share
          information about arriving fugitive slaves with contacts in the South.
          This nascent reverse Underground Railroad network took advantage of
          both the telegraph and railroad lines to speed communication and travel
          between Harrisburg, Maryland, and Virginia. Harrisburg residents witnessed,
          in the years of McAllister’s reign as Commissioner, the spiriting
          of captured fugitive slaves out of town and back into slavery not by
          wagon, as had been the custom of slave catchers prior to this, but
          by train.  Although
          McAllister became ineffective after 1853, the network of anti-fugitive
          informers in Harrisburg remained active through the Civil War. Joseph
          Bustill, by making use of the telegraph and railroad in his operation,
          was merely fighting back with the technology available.  This did
          not mean that the Rutherfords, Kelkers, and other Underground Railroad
          activists located outside of the borough were cut out of the operation
          after 1856. All still remained a vital part of the network, although
          their role seems to have switched from actively forwarding fugitives
          to the hiding, support, and care of fugitives. The Rutherford Farms
          continued to be excellent locations to house arriving fugitive slaves
          who were not being hotly pursued. In some cases, fugitives remained
          either in town or on the outlying farms for extended periods, working
          as farm hands for their bed and board.  Joseph Bustill,
          in his letter to William Still that was hand delivered by John F. Williams,
          mentioned a woman that “has been here some time waiting for her
          child and her beau, which she expects here about the first of June.” That
          woman, in all likelihood, was Jane Johnson, aged twenty-two, who arrived
          at Still’s office along with another woman on 12 June. In his
          notes, Still recorded that Johnson "when in Harrisburg went by
          the name of Jane Wellington," and that she "was owned by
          David Beiller...who lived near Hagerstown."123 Bustill
          and his network found lodging for her somewhere in Harrisburg or the
          vicinity, while she waited for the arrival of her husband.  William W.
          Rutherford, for his part, continued to maintain an active political
          and social presence, through which he advocated and lobbied against
          the Fugitive Slave Law and in favor of abolitionist policies. There
          were also plenty of instances in which resourceful fugitive slaves
          managed to reach Harrisburg without having made contact with any Underground
          Railroad operators, found just enough aid to sustain themselves from
          local residents who were not a formal part of Bustill’s operation,
          and moved on by foot, continuing to follow the river or the mountains
          north, completely unknown to Bustill or his workers.  Four such
          fugitive slaves, who reached Harrisburg in late August or early September
          1856 completely on their own, were fortunately turned over to Bustill’s
          care after they arrived in town and were sent by him to Philadelphia.
          George Solomon had been owned by Daniel Minor, of Moss Grove, Virginia;
          Benjamin R. Fletcher escaped from slaveholder Henry Martin in Washington
          DC; and Daniel Neal and Maria Dorsey, a widow, had both been owned
          by the grocer George Parker in Washington, DC. All four somehow became
          acquainted with each other in the national capital and together made
          plans for escape. They put their plan into action that summer and walked
          the entire distance from Washington to Harrisburg. After being taken
          in by Bustill’s activists in Harrisburg, the four were sent to
          William Still, who was able to forward them almost immediately to Canada.124  During the
          last week of December 1856, a cold and hungry Robert Brown, of Martinsburg,
          Virginia, bearing no supplies or possessions other than a photographic
          image and locks of hair from the family that was sold away from him
          a few weeks earlier, arrived in Harrisburg. Brown, like the four fugitives
          from Washington, DC, had been unable to make contact with any activists
          prior to his arrival in Harrisburg. He was taken in, fed, rested, and
          given medical attention until he was deemed well enough to travel,
          then forwarded by train to Philadelphia, arriving there late on New
          Years Day, 1857. Philadelphia agents were waiting at the Reading depot
          for him, having been alerted to Brown’s imminent arrival by a
          telegram from Joseph Bustill.125  These were
          the successes enjoyed by Joseph Bustill and the Harrisburg activists
          after local operations had been revived and updated for the times,
          but pro-Southern sympathizers and the foes of abolition remained very
          strong in central Pennsylvania, causing the local anti-slavery resistance
          to remain secretive and constantly on guard.  An incident
          in Carlisle showed just how impotent rescue operations could be in
          the face of a hostile local population. In the late summer or early
          fall of 1856, a party of fugitive slaves arrived in Carlisle, probably
          having been sent north from activists in the Quaker Valley region of
          Adams County. Waiting at Carlisle, however, were a group of slave catchers
          from Virginia, who arrested the fugitives and took them to the railroad
          station for the return trip south. At that point: 
         An attempt
              was made by the free negroes, and a few white men present, to ‘raise
              a row,’ but the United States Marshal was promptly in attendance
              and took them into custody. The Mayor of the town then addressed
              the crowd, and told them that these citizens of a sister State
              were there in pursuance of a law, recover their property, and that
              they must not be molested. The great majority of the audience heartily
              seconded his remarks, and declared that they would sustain him.
              After the investigation was had, and the slaves were proved and
              identified, the officers summoned a small posse to accompany them
              out of the State, and although there was a considerable crowd at
              the Marshal’s office at the time, they were passed through
              without the slightest disturbances.126    Previous |
            Next   Notes113. Still, Underground
            Rail Road, 321.  114. Ibid.,
          322  115. Ibid.,
          323  116. Ibid. While
          newly settled in Canada, Otho Taylor made frequent requests to William
          Still for funds to finance his plan for a raid into Maryland to rescue
          additional family members. He even risked recapture in August 1856
          by returning to the United States to visit Still at Philadelphia to
          make a personal appeal for funding. Still, however, had to disappoint
          the would-be raider “as but little encouragement could be held
          out to such projects” due not only to the inherent danger, but
          also to lack of funds “for this kind of work.” At some
          point, Otho Taylor settled in Harrisburg. He is found in post-Civil
          War city directories (1866, 1867-68 and 1869), living in Tanner’s
          Alley near Cranberry Alley, and is enumerated in the 1870 Census, living
          in the city’s Eight Ward. Bureau of the Census, 1870 Census,
          Harrisburg, Dauphin County, Pennsylvania.  117. Still, Underground
            Rail Road, 323. Regarding the relationship between the freedom
            seekers, William Still noted “What relations had previously
            existed between David and this lady in Virginia, the Committee knew
            not…The Underground Rail Road never practiced the proscription
            governing other roads, on account of race, color, or previous condition.” Additional
            details are from Vigilance Committee of Philadelphia, Journal
            C of Station No. 2, William Still, 1856 (hereafter Still Journal
            C), page 11, published online by the Historical Society of Pennsylvania, http://www.hsp.org/default.aspx?id=993 (accessed
            26 November 2009). This entry gives the date of arrival of Lewis,
            Mahoney and her daughter as June 3, whereas in his published book,
            Still gives the date of arrival as May 31.  118.	Still, Underground
            Rail Road, 220; Still Journal C, 10. Again, Still’s
            journal gives slightly different details from the published book.
            In the journal, the six freedom seekers from Hagerstown arrived on
            June 3, 1856, rather than on May 31. The journal only notes George
            Dorsey as fighting with the white attackers, while the book includes
            Charles Bird as helping to defend the wagon.  119. Still, Underground
            Rail Road, 218. How Schaeffer got word that his slaves were
            being sent to Philadelphia by train is not known. Still’s account
            of the police officer’s story suggests that Joseph C. Bustill’s
            operation in Harrisburg was being closely monitored by someone in
            town who was opposed to his activities. This is not inconsistent
            with the political and social makeup of Harrisburg’s population
            during this period in history.  120.	Ibid.  121. Ibid.,
          219.  122. Ibid.,
          323. The term “lightening train” indicates an express run.
          Bustill’s capitalization of the term is not necessarily significant.
          Because it stops at few stations between major towns, the train seems
          to have gotten its name from the speed with which it passes smaller
          stations, unlike a regular passenger or freight run, which stops at
          every station. In 1854, the New York Times reported that a
          lightning train from Pittsburgh to Philadelphia, over the Pennsylvania
          Railroad lines, arrived in twelve and a half hours. New York Times,
          10 July 1854.  123.	Still Journal,
          vol. C, 285.  124. Ibid. It
          is possible all four slaves met at the grocery business of George Parker.
          George Parker (1800-1876) was, in partnership with his brother Thomas
          Parker, a leading grocer in Washington, DC, and his store, Parker & Company,
          Grocers, was located on the North Side of Pennsylvania Avenue, opposite
          Centre Market. His obituary notes “The Parker family were numbered
          in past years among the wealthy residents of the city and their entertainments
          were a feature in social circles.” The family home was a three
          story brownstone mansion built by Joseph B. Bryan in 1843 at the southeast
          corner of Four-and-One-Half and C Streets. “Death of Mr. George
          Parker,” Evening Star, 11 December 1876; Zevely, Old
          Houses on C Street, Columbia Historical Society, in “Interments
          in the Historic Congressional Cemetery,” Association for the
          Preservation of the Historic Congressional Cemetery, Washington, DC, http://www.congressionalcemetery.org/ (accessed
          27 November 2009).  125. Still, Underground
            Rail Road, 121-122.  126. Liberator,
          17 October 1856.
 
 |