|   Table
              of Contents Study
            Areas: Enslavement Anti-Slavery Free
            Persons of Color Underground
            Railroad The
            Violent Decade  US
            Colored Troops Civil
            War  
     |   Chapter
            NineDeluge
  
For
              Harrisburg blacks, the decade-long nightmare that
              was the 1850s—a period that began in a bloody riot and spiraled
              through years of state-sponsored kidnappings, beatings, and legal
              assaults on African American rights—showed no signs of dissipating
              into the hope of a sunny morning. If anything, Harrisburg’s
              African American residents were rudely awakened from the plodding
              nightmare only to face the thunderclaps of a violent storm. So
              ended a decade that refused to pass quietly into history.  The
          town, which was growing large enough to be on the verge of being officially
          classified as a city, continued to attract attention from the movers
          and shakers of the anti-slavery movement. William Lloyd Garrison returned
          to Harrisburg during a “rapid anti-slavery tour” through
          Pennsylvania to Ohio, eleven years after he was greeted with a shower
          of rotten eggs and bricks while attempting to speak at the courthouse
          during his first visit to town in 1847. This trip would prove to be
          less confrontational.  Garrison
          made stops in Philadelphia, Germantown—where he stayed the night
          in the home of J. Miller McKim and sipped tea with Lucretia Mott and
          other local Quaker activists who had come to call on him—and
          West Chester, where he and the other guests at the McKim estate took
          part in a three day celebration of the anniversary of the founding
          of the Pennsylvania Anti-Slavery Society. From West Chester, Garrison
          and his party took the train to Paoli and then to Christiana, probably
          following the same route taken by Edward Gorsuch and his men six years
          earlier. The abolitionist editor was met at the Christiana train station
          by the venerable Thomas Whitson, who welcomed him into his farmhouse
          for the two-day stay, during which time Garrison delivered lectures
          on Saturday at the local schoolhouse and on Sunday at the Friends Meeting
          House in Bart Township.  On
          the way back to Whitson’s farm, Garrison and his party played
          the part of tourists, stopping at the William Parker farm to examine
          the spot where Edward Gorsuch was killed. Garrison was deeply moved
          as he walked up the dirt lane to the old “riot house.” Like
          many other curious visitors, the staid Boston newspaperman stopped
          to reflect on the historical events as he surveyed the front yard,
          then “had the satisfaction to place my foot upon the threshold” of
          the storied log house, dubbing the site “Bunker Hill and Lexington;”1 a
          highly significant metaphor for another equally venerated revolution
          seventy-six years earlier.  Garrison
          left Christiana on the Monday morning train for Harrisburg, and, as
          on his previous visit in 1847, was again welcomed at the Market Street
          depot “by my old friend, Dr. W. W. Rutherford, and cordially
          welcomed to his residence.” Doctor William Wilson Rutherford
          and his wife Eleanor again played the part of gracious hosts to the
          traveling abolitionist editor, opening their Front Street townhouse
          to him so he could rest up from his journey.  While
          there, Dr. Rutherford filled Garrison in on the details of the arrangements
          he had made to allow him to deliver an anti-slavery lecture in town
          later that evening, on 11 October. Despite advertisements that had
          been placed to promote the event, Garrison’s audience numbered
          only about twenty-five persons, “the smallest I ever addressed,” but
          he did not let the dismal turnout, or a persistent hoarseness from
          a week of lecturing, deter him from delivering a powerful ninety-minute
          oration. Garrison blamed the poor response on the fact that the next
          day, Tuesday the twelfth, was election day, and “political excitement
          was at fever heat…Besides this, a circus had come into the town
          that day; and a fat woman, weighing several hundred pounds, three living
          male skeletons, and a huge boa constrictor, were on exhibition!...
          Moreover, the place has a large foreign population, wholly inaccessible.”  Disappointed,
          Garrison bid goodbye to the Rutherfords and moved on the next day for
          Altoona.2 In Harrisburg,
          the local papers took little notice of his appearance or his speech.   Arrival
          of a "Most Determined Abolitionist" Another
          well-known anti-slavery activist had also taken a keen interest in
          central Pennsylvania at about this same time. This person, however,
          was not looking to publicize a lecture tour, and in fact was intentionally
          keeping a low profile, at times even hiding out in the homes of African
          American sympathizers to escape federal authorities who were on his
          trail. The man was “Captain” John Brown, the Kansas Territory
          legend—“Old Osawatomie”— who was partly responsible
          for the blood in “Bleeding Kansas,” and he had come east
          again with a plan to battle slavery on its own soil.  Brown
          was born a Connecticut Yankee, in a fiercely religious family. His
          father, a tanner, held deep anti-slavery views, teaching his son that
          slavery was a sin against God. The family moved to Ohio when John Brown
          was a child, and during the War of 1812, the young man drove cattle
          to army encampments in Michigan. It was in Michigan that John Brown
          first witnessed the horrors of slavery, and from that point on, he
          became, in his words, “a most determined Abolitionist.”  Brown
          studied at a divinity school with an eye toward becoming a minister,
          but ended his studies when he ran out of money. He married and fathered
          seven children, with the birth of the last child leading to his wife’s
          early death. He remarried and fathered another thirteen children, and
          spent the better portion of the next two decades moving in and out
          of various occupations, as he moved his large family back and forth
          through five states in the East.  His
          family spent a decade in Northwestern Pennsylvania, where John Brown
          operated a tannery and served as the postmaster of the little town
          of Randolph (later renamed New Richmond), near Meadville, in Crawford
          County.3 Here he was
          a town leader, school founder and teacher, lay minister, librarian,
          doctor, veterinarian, and ultimately a full time caregiver to his children
          as his wife’s health faded and then failed.4  He
          kept alive his hatred of slavery, and the location became an active
          station on the Underground Railroad during the Browns’ tenure
          there. John Brown intently followed national events that related to
          slavery, and after the Southampton Revolt of 1831, he counted Nat Turner
          as one of his heroes.5 His
          anti-slavery beliefs soon drew him out west to Kansas Territory, where
          he participated in the epic struggle for control of that land, and
          as a result became a figure of legendary admiration, or dread.  By
          early 1858, John Brown had returned from Kansas Territory with an audacious
          and revolutionary plan that would outdo even the mini-“Bunker
          Hill and Lexington” at the Parker Riot House in Christiana. It
          seems that he had always planned to stage a showdown with the slave
          powers, in some form or the other. He had begun the struggle on his
          New Richmond farm, providing aid to a large number of fugitive slaves
          who passed through the area, but even then, he had larger plans, and
          the works of the Underground Railroad provided the inspiration for
          his grand scheme.  He
          studied southern geography with an eye toward establishing remote outposts
          to which slaves could flee, and in time be sent to safety. The Allegheny
          Mountain range stood out to him as a beacon of possibilities, and the
          more he studied the massive 400-mile range that extended from Pennsylvania
          down through Virginia, the more he realized it was exactly what he
          had been seeking. He told militant abolitionist and close personal
          supporter Thomas Wentworth Higginson, “God had established the
          Allegheny Mountains from the foundation of the world that they might
          one day be a refuge for fugitive slaves.”6  In
          its final form, Brown’s plan envisioned an independent mountain
          fortress in the heights of western Virginia, from which guerilla operations
          against the local slave powers could be staged. As one of the participants,
          John H. Kagi, a schoolteacher, lawyer, and veteran of the Kansas bloodshed,
          explained it, the first stage was to appear as “a local insurrection,
          at most. The planters would pursue their chattel and be defeated. The
          militia would then be called out, and would also be defeated. It was
          not intended that the movement should appear to be of large dimension,
          but that, gradually increasing in magnitude, it should, as it opened,
          strike terror into the heart of the slave states.”7  The
          operation was, at its heart, a terrorist strike into the South. The
          plan assumed that local slaves, once they understood what was happening,
          would flock to the mountains to join in, thus strengthening their numbers
          and increasing their confidence, which would in turn inspire more slave “stampedes.” Additional
          mountain outposts and remote camps would be built, creating a chain
          of maroon-type resistance from the free north all the way to the swamps
          of South Carolina. Brown himself designed many of the planned fortresses,
          based upon personal inspections of the ruins of medieval fortifications
          in France and Germany that he made during a trip to Europe in 1849.8  In
          February 1858, Brown traveled to the home of Frederick Douglass, in
          Rochester, New York, to work on his plans and to arrange for financial
          support. It was at Douglass’ home that Brown composed his “Provisional
          Constitution and Ordinances for the People of the United States,” a
          massive reform of the Constitution of the United States. The second
          paragraph of his constitution, which followed an opening paragraph
          that undeniably denounced slavery, stated: 
        We, the citizens of
              the United States, and the oppressed people, who, by a recent decision
              of the Supreme Court are declared to have no rights which the White
              Man is bound to respect; together with all of the people degraded
              by the laws thereof, Do, for the time being ordain and establish
              ourselves the following Provisional Constitution and Ordinances,
              the better to protect our Persons, Property, Lives, and Liberties;
              and to govern our actions: And following
          that, under “Article I,” was listed the qualifications
          for full citizenship, which specified, “All persons of mature
          age, whether Proscribed, oppressed, and enslaved Citizens, or of the
          Proscribed and oppressed races of the United States.” In short,
          all people against whom any sort of prejudice had traditionally been
          manifested. John Brown scholar David S. Reynolds noted, “Brown’s
          main focus, then, was America’s most oppressed group, African
          Americans; but by implication he encompassed other maltreated groups
          as well, such as women, children, and Native Americans and other ethnic
          minorities. Brown’s constitution was unprecedented with regard
          to its inclusiveness with regard to race, gender, and age.”9   People of
          the Reliable KindIt was also
          during his stay at Frederick Douglass’ home that Brown revealed
          his intense interest in central Pennsylvania. In a February 1858 letter
          to his son, John Brown, Jr., the elder Brown wrote, “I have been
          thinking that I would like to have you make a trip to Bedford, Chambersburg,
          Gettysburg and Uniontown, in Pennsylvania, travelling slowly along,
          and inquiring out every man on the way, or every family of the right
          stripe, and getting acquainted with them as much as you could. When
          you look at the location of those places, you will readily perceive
          the advantage of getting up some acquaintance in those parts.”10 In
          a follow up letter, written from Chatham, Ontario, in April, Brown
          reminded his son about “hunting up every person and family of
          the reliable kind about, at, or near Bedford, Chambersburg, Gettysburg,
          and Carlisle, in Pennsylvania, and also Hagerstown and vicinity, Maryland,
          and Harpers Ferry, Va.”11  The elder
          Brown was drafting a distinct line of support and communication from
          the towns west and south of Harrisburg to his target in the mountains
          of western Virginia. What, exactly, he had planned for this region
          remained to be seen. From Rochester, Douglass and Brown traveled to
          Philadelphia to meet with Henry Highland Garnet, Stephen Smith, and
          other African American leaders at Stephen Smith’s Lombard Street
          home.12 The plan was
          quickly coming together.  The meeting
          occurred in Smith’s house at 921 Lombard Street on 10 March,
          a Wednesday. With Brown and Douglass was Brown’s eldest son,
          John Jr., Henry Highland Garnet, and William Still. There, in the flickering
          lamplight, Brown laid out his invasion plan to the leaders of the local
          African American community. His success, the old man knew, depended
          upon the moral, if not financial backing, of the Northern free African
          American community, but until now, he had shared his plans with precious
          few people. For this meeting he had chosen to reveal the grand plan
          to those he considered not only trustworthy, but also radical enough
          to accept actions that would surely be considered treasonous and terroristic.  Henry Highland
          Garnet, though a Presbyterian minister, was already known to be in
          that very militant frame of mind, but the other man of God in the room,
          the Reverend Stephen Smith, an ordained minister in the A.M.E. church,
          did not have the same reputation. Smith, who had been born into slavery
          in Dauphin County, sold to a master in Columbia, purchased his freedom,
          and rose to national prominence through decades of hard work and shrewd
          business practices, still maintained close ties with his business partner
          in Columbia, William Whipper.  Despite moving
          to Philadelphia in 1842, Smith shared Whipper’s concern for the
          citizens of Columbia and for the safe conduct of fugitive slaves throughout
          the region. He no doubt shared Whipper’s anguish over the murder
          of lumber worker and fugitive slave William Smith in 1852, but whether
          he was so deeply affected by the incident to embrace militant abolitionism
          at that time is not clear. However, the presence of John Brown in his
          parlor in March 1858,13 explaining
          to Philadelphia area African American leaders his plan to establish
          a guerrilla resistance in the Appalachian Mountains, speaks much to
          Smith’s conflicted frame of mind near the end of the decade.  William Still,
          as head of the Philadelphia Vigilance Committee, was sympathetic toward
          John Brown’s anti-slavery work, but also, through Still’s
          connections, was the Bustill family. While in Philadelphia in March,
          Brown and his son stayed at the home of painter David Bustill Bowser,
          a grandson of Cyrus Bustill, Underground Railroad worker and cousin
          to Joseph Bustill.14 Everyone
          at the meeting in Smith’s home was considered by Brown to be
          a trusted potential supporter, if not actual conspirator and participant
          in the plans that he now passionately laid out for them.  There was
          one person in the room, however, who had known Brown’s aspirations
          for armed resistance for many years. In 1847, just after his speaking
          tour with William Lloyd Garrison through Pennsylvania and Ohio, Frederick
          Douglass made a trip to the home of John Brown in Springfield, Ohio.
          Brown had been recommended to him by his friends Henry Highland Garnet
          and Reverend Jermain Wesley Loguen, whose voices, in speaking of Brown “would
          drop to a whisper.” Douglass eagerly accepted an invitation to
          visit Brown, at the time a successful merchant, at his home.  The abolitionist
          lecturer expected to find “a fine residence in an eligible location,” but
          instead found that the earnest Brown and his family inhabited “a
          small wooden building on a back street, in a neighborhood chiefly occupied
          by laboring men and mechanics.” It was there, in an abode in
          which “everything implied stern truth, solid purpose, and rigid
          economy,” that Douglass first heard the entire ambitious plan
          that was John Brown’s vision. It was a secret that Douglass carried
          with him for eleven years, until this meeting in the home of Stephen
          Smith, when Old Osawatomie carefully expanded his pool of African American
          men “to whom he could safely reveal his secret.”15  Brown made
          other important Pennsylvania connections during this time, writing
          letters to Martin R. Delany while staying with Frederick Douglass,
          visiting with other Philadelphia area black leaders while at the Bowser
          household in Philadelphia, and finally, firming up his network with
          a visit to the free African communities in Canada.  His first
          destination north of the United States-Canada border was significant:
          Brown traveled with Reverend Jermain W. Loguen to St. Catharines, the
          site of a settlement populated by a large number of fugitive slaves,
          including many who had passed through central Pennsylvania. One prominent
          resident in particular intrigued John Brown, and he had Loguen take
          him straight to her door. Harriet Tubman welcomed John Brown into her
          home on North Street, in St. Catharines, Canada West on 7 April 1858.  She had established
          herself in a small community of former slaves from the Eastern Shore
          of Maryland, the area from which she herself had escaped nine years
          prior, and the area to which she had heroically returned time and again
          to retrieve members of her family from bondage.16 Once
          settled in St. Catharines, Tubman formed alliances with local and regional
          anti-slavery organizations, both black and white, to form a network
          of relief agencies for the support of newly arrived fugitives. She
          worked among the local African American residents, helping them to
          find homes and work, a vocation that suited her nickname among the
          immigrant community there as “Moses.”  John Brown
          came to her house and spoke to an assembled group of local African
          American residents, most of them escaped slaves, about his visions
          of resistance, and in short order he had won over not only many of
          the assembled people, but Moses herself, whom Brown dubbed “General” Tubman.17  On Saturday,
          8 May, Brown “quietly” convened a convention of African
          American leaders, ostensibly at the First Baptist Church on King Street
          (but held at various nearby buildings), under the ruse that they were
          organizing a Masonic Lodge, in nearby Chatham, Canada West. At this
          convention, he presented his provisional constitution for ratification
          by the delegates present and had it printed by newspaperman and printer
          William Howard Day. Brown had corresponded with Day the previous month,
          exchanging information about Harriet Tubman’s activities, and
          the newspaperman maintained a close working relationship with Brown
          while the activist was in Canada West.18  Brown also
          made personal contact with, and secured cooperation from, Martin R.
          Delany while in Canada, another significant accomplishment for the
          self-appointed resistance commander. One other Pennsylvanian was recruited
          during this time: Osborne Perry Anderson, a free born African American
          resident of Chester County, Pennsylvania was working in Chatham as
          a printer on the staff of the Provincial
          Freeman, Mary Ann Shadd’s newspaper, and attended
          Brown’s convention.19 Anderson
          had moved to Canada West to manage the farm of Mary Ann Shadd’s
          uncle, Absolom Shadd, and became involved with the newspaper as early
          as 1856. Anderson had previously studied at Oberlin College, knew William
          Howard Day, who had moved to a farm in Dresden, Canada West, in 1857,
          and worked closely with him in various anti-slavery capacities while
          in Canada.20 Brown’s
          groundwork to establish connections in Pennsylvania, a vital part of
          his planning, was almost finished.   The Chambersburg "Mining" OperationMore than
          a year of preparations passed between the secret Chatham convention
          and the establishment of a forward base of operations at Chambersburg,
          Pennsylvania. In that town, John Kagi, one of John Brown’s lieutenants,
          operating under the pseudonym J. Henrie, had opened a false Virginia
          mining business named Isaac Smith and Sons.  In June 1859,
          at Chambersburg, Kagi received a shipment by rail of fifteen crates,
          shipped by John Brown, Jr. from Ohio. The crates, which were stenciled
          with the words “mining equipment” on the outside, were
          delivered to Kagi’s fake business storefront. Actually, the crates
          contained enough weapons to equip about two companies of men: 198 Sharps
          rifles and 200 Maynard revolvers.  John Brown,
          Sr., under the pseudonym of Doctor Isaac Smith, and several other conspirators
          posing as his mining venture associates, joined Kagi briefly in Chambersburg
          that June before heading further south to Hagerstown, and then to Harpers
          Ferry by early July.21 While
          in Chambersburg, Brown and his men stayed at the East King Street boarding
          house of Mary Ritner, the widowed daughter-in-law of former Pennsylvania
          governor Joseph Ritner. Mary Ritner’s husband Abram had supposedly
          been an abolitionist, which may have led John Brown, Jr. to her while
          he was scouting the town for people “of the right stripe” for
          his father the previous year.  While working
          in Chambersburg, Kagi had the help of local Underground Railroad agents
          Henry and Eliza Watson, who provided him with intelligence and extra
          help to watch for arms shipments. Henry Watson was a forty-seven-year-old
          African American barber, born in Maryland, and Eliza, at age forty-three,
          worked as a washerwoman in town. They owned a small property in the
          town’s South Ward 22 and
          were probably the agents who helped forward fugitives Owen and Otho
          Taylor, and their families, to Joseph Bustill in Harrisburg in 1856.  On Friday
          evening, 19 August 1859, Henry Watson was working in his barbershop
          when two African American men walked through his door. One of the men
          was a stranger to him, but the other was instantly recognizable as
          Frederick Douglass. The presence of the abolitionist orator in Chambersburg
          was a surprise to many of the local residents, as the appearance of
          a nationally known figure of his prominence would normally have been
          well advertised in advance, but Watson was not caught off guard. He
          had recently been asked to keep a watch for Douglass by none other
          than John Brown himself, in the character of Isaac Smith, who was again
          in town.  Brown had
          sent word to Douglass in Rochester, New York, that he needed to see
          him as soon as possible, and he directed him to find him at an abandoned
          stone quarry in Chambersburg. Douglass, accompanied by Shields Green,
          a young man that Brown had met at his house in Rochester the previous
          year, left Rochester on Tuesday the sixteenth for Chambersburg and
          upon arrival immediately sought out their contact, Henry Watson, who “dropped
          all and put [Douglass] on the right track” to meet Brown.  Watson directed
          the men to a secluded area west of town, at the Conococheague Creek,
          where they found Brown and Kagi waiting in the old quarry. Brown was
          disguised as a fisherman and did not immediately recognize Douglass,
          but even after they recognized and greeted each other, Douglass recalled
          that the old man “wore an anxious expression,” the stress
          of planning the operation obviously wearing on him.23  Douglass
          reported that “We—Mr. Kagi, Captain Brown, Shields Green,
          and myself—sat down among the rocks and talked over the enterprise
          which was about to be undertaken,” discussing the details, the
          purpose, the vision, the problems, and the moral issues involved, spending “the
          most of Saturday and a part of Sunday in this debate.”  Douglass
          tried his best to dissuade Brown from the venture, arguing that he
          was going into “a perfect steel trap” and that “once
          in, he would never get out alive.” Brown, he noted, listened
          to his views with respect, but countered each point with his own, and
          could not be shaken from his plan.  As darkness
          approached on Saturday evening, Douglass returned to town, where, to
          cover his real reason for being in Chambersburg, he delivered a speech
          in favor of immediate emancipation and equality of the races. The Valley
          Spirit newspaper reported that his “discourse was well received
          by a large and attentive auditory [sic],” and that the speaker
          was “impressive” in his elocution.24  On Sunday,
          he and Green were again at the quarry, meeting with Brown and Kagi.
          The discussion on the Sabbath was not as extensive, and after a short
          session, Douglass decided that he had no more arguments for Brown,
          and that the old campaigner would not heed them anyway. He told Shields
          Green that he had heard what John Brown had to say, that he disagreed
          with the changes in the plan and that he planned to return to Rochester
          and that Green was welcome to come with him. Brown rose and clasped
          Douglass on the shoulders, urging both him and Green to join him in
          Virginia, telling Douglass, “When I strike, the bees will begin
          to swarm, and I shall want you to help hive them.”  Douglass
          was affected by Brown’s depth of affection for him, but believed
          nothing good could come from the raid on a federal arsenal, believing
          it to be not only foolhardy, but futile, and he refused the offer,
          later candidly recalling that he was not sure if his choice was motivated
          more out of discretion or cowardice. He prepared to leave Brown in
          the quarry, and, turning to Green, asked what he had decided to do.  Shields Green
          was in his twenties, and had escaped slavery in Charleston, South Carolina
          some years before. Douglass was therefore surprised to hear the former
          slave tell him, “I believe I’ll go with the old man,”25 understanding
          full well that he was dooming himself either to death, or a return
          to slavery. Douglass returned to town, leaving Green, Brown, and Kagi
          in the quarry. It was the last he would see any of them.    Previous |
            Next   Notes1. “Letter
          From the Editor,” Liberator, 22 October 1858.  2.	Ibid.  3. John
            Brown’s Raid, National Park Service History Series (Washington,
            DC: NPS Office of Publications, 1973), 2-5.  4. David S.
          Reynolds, John Brown, Abolitionist: The Man Who Killed Slavery,
          Sparked the Civil War, and Seeded Civil Rights (New York: Knopf,
          2005), 44-52.  5.	Ibid., 54-55.  6. W. E. B.
          DuBois, John Brown (1909; repr., New York: Modern Library,
          2001), 117. Higginson was one of Brown’s “Secret Six,” financial
          backers of his revolutionary plans. The others were Samuel Howe, Theodore
          Parker, Franklin Benjamin Sanborn, Gerrit Smith and George Luther Stearns.  7. Ibid., xxviii,
          117, 133.  8.	Ibid.  9.	Reynolds, John
            Brown, 249-252. Brown’s Provisional Constitution, after
            it was ratified at the African American convention in Chatham, Canada
            West (Ontario) in May, was printed for private distribution by Oberlin
            College graduate and Aliened American newspaper publisher
            William Howard Day. Day maintained close ties with John Brown, exchanging
            correspondence with him in the spring of 1858 as an intermediary
            between Brown and Harriet Tubman. Kate Clifford Larson, Bound
            for the Promised Land. Harriet Tubman, Portrait of an American Hero (New
            York: Random House, One World, 2004), 160.  10. Franklin
          Benjamin Sanborn, The Life and Letters of John Brown: Liberator
          of Kansas and Martyr of Virginia, 3rd ed. (Boston: Roberts Brothers,
          1885), 450.  11. Ibid., 452.  12. Ibid., 451.  13. DuBois, John
            Brown, 147. The murdered fugitive William Smith was no relation
            to the philanthropist and businessman Stephen Smith.  14. Like his
          Harrisburg cousin, David Bustill Bowser worked to aid fugitive slaves,
          and even used his home to provide shelter. During, or shortly after
          the time that Brown stayed in the his home, Bowser produced a painting
          of Brown showing the old man with his full gray beard—an image
          that would become known throughout the world following his 1859 raid
          and trial. Eric Ledell Smith, “Painted with Pride in the U.S.A," Pennsylvania
          Heritage 27, no. 1 (Winter 2001): 24-31.  15.	DuBois, John
            Brown, 56-59.  16. Harriet
          Tubman made about thirteen trips to the Eastern Shore of Maryland between
          1850 and 1860, leading away about seventy persons, mostly family members
          and friends. This astounding record of rescues in the face of certain
          re-enslavement, had she been caught, was what brought John Brown to
          her door in Canada West in April 1858. She was known for her planning,
          caution, intuitive sense of impending danger, and her strong command
          of those in her charge while on the road—all qualities needed
          and sought by Brown. Harriet Tubman favored following the waterways
          of the Eastern Shore of Maryland—an area with which she was intimately
          familiar—for her escape routes to the north, and therefore she
          never brought fugitives through central Pennsylvania, preferring instead
          to go through agents Thomas Garrett in Wilmington, Delaware and William
          Still in Philadelphia. The town of St. Catharines, however, was home
          to hundreds of other fugitive slaves who had passed through central
          Pennsylvania—people like Owen and Otho Taylor—who received
          resettlement aid from Tubman once in Canada West. Larson, Bound
          for the Promised Land, xxii-xxiii, 157-160, 302.  17. Ibid., 158-160.  18. Ibid., 160;
          DuBois, John Brown, 152-153.  19. Jean Libby, “Osborne
          Perry Anderson (1830-1871),” at “John Brown Research,” Allies
          for Freedom, http://www.alliesforfreedom.org/opa.htm (accessed
          28 December 2009).  20. Jane Rhodes, Mary
            Ann Shadd Cary: The Black Press and Protest in the Nineteenth Century (Bloomington:
            Indiana University Press, 1998), 114, 118, 130-132.  21. Reynolds, John
            Brown, 294-295; Alexander K. McClure, Old Time Notes of
            Pennsylvania (Philadelphia: John C. Winston, 1905), 360.  22. Bureau of
          the Census, 1860 Census, South Ward, Chambersburg, Franklin County,
          PA.  23. Frederick
          Douglass, The Life and Times of Frederick Douglass (1881;
          repr., New York: Pathway Press, 1941), 350-354; Sanborn, Life and
          Letters, 538. The site of the old quarry and the meeting is marked by a PHMC historical
        marker. It is located on West Washington Street, in Chambersburg, behind
        the Southgate Mall, near the bridge over the creek and just east of the
        intersection of Franklin Street and Route 30.
  24.	Douglass, Life
            and Times, 351-353; Valley Spirit, 24 August 1859.  25.	Douglass, Life
            and Times, 353-354.
 
 
 |